25 January 2010

Review: Courtney Milan - Proof By Seduction

~purchase a copy here~
~website author~

Mass Market Paperback: 352 pages
Publisher: HQN Books (January 1, 2010)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0373774397
ISBN-13: 978-0373774395

Genre: Historical Romance
Main Characters: Gareth, Jenny and Ned.
Book Origin: Via Netgalley Harlequin provided me with an E-ARC

Cover Summary:
She is his last chance for a future of happiness.
Jenny Keeble has never let her humble upbringing stop her. She’s made her way in the world as a fortune teller, one who convinces her clients her predictions are correct by telling them what they most want to hear. Business is good… until she meets her match in the form of Gareth Carhart, the Marquess of Blakely, a scientist and sworn bachelor.
He just doesn’t know it yet.

Broodingly handsome, Gareth is appalled to discover his cousin has fallen under the spell of "Madame Esmerelda," and he vows to prove her a fraud. But his unexpected attraction to the fiery enchantress defies logic. Jenny disrupts every facet of Gareth's calculated plan— until he can’t decide whether to ruin her or claim her for his own. Now, as they engage in a passionate battle of wills, two lonely souls must choose between everything they know . . . and the boundless possibilities of love.

Courtney Milan has proven to be one of those authors who can deliver a story for me that I start in and hours later can close with an utter feeling of romantic satisfaction. Her prose provides a flow in the story that is both easily read and certain phrasing comes across as befitting of the time period. Yet most of all I really enjoyed her descriptions that could instantly set the tone or describe unique character traits. Like the following; ‘his eyes were those of a lion; tawny, ferocious and more than a little feral.’ It instantly added a raw, unpredictable edge to Gareth that was contradicting his rigid attitude of propriety and responsibility.

If there is one thing that I can say about this debut novel is that Milan excels in characterization. Especially the three who took such a prominent role in PROOF BY SEDUCTION. The first on that really wooed me with his personality is Gareth, I just can’t help but love a man who knows he is imperfect but can’t help himself from acting or responding in a certain way. His upbringing is part to blame and Gareth is stuck in a pattern of behavior that will need a stubborn woman to shake him out of. As I gradually read the chapters I was more and more enamored by Gareth, his social skills are a nightmare, yet he is also passionate and most of the times so very formal in his behavior. The alternation between these intriguing sides of him was a heady mix to take in as a reader.

Now Esmerelda aka Jenny Keeble was a heroine I mostly liked. She matched her intellect and wit with Gareth and it delivers heated dialogues. Their clash of gender is at times so hungry for connection, to draw one another out of their shell and it takes a better part of the story to lay it all bare for each other. Jenny is confronted with her decisions, her actions and the repercussions from it. She has to make amends and Gareth saw straight through her fake persona of Mme. Esmerelda. For all her bold, courageous ways there was an occasion or two where I felt she was a little haughty, like she had all the wisdom to teach Gareth what to do and how to do it.

As Gareth and Jenny developed an intricate relationship with each other I felt that it wouldn’t have happened the way it all did, had it not been for Ned. He is the kind of supportive character that adds a unique point of view to the story. He is young enough for stupid mistakes, serious enough to show the incredible mature man he is going to be with still the loyalty and eagerness of his young age. He is this vibrant character who I cherished throughout the story and I was ecstatic to find he is going to have his own story. Because if there is one thing that Courtney Milan has given him in Proof By Seduction is a buildup of character that screams to be explored further.

Along with the characters that made a lasting impression on me I found out this author managed to make the chemistry express itself mainly via interaction and body language but is very mild on the actual love making. In this day and age the heat level can be far more scorching but this story was more reminiscent of the more older historical romances. Though I’m not a fan of ballroom settings it was the prose of Milan that fueled my imagination with rich colored fabrics, environment and dressed-up people. She made the scenes exhilaration to explore from a society ball to the working class house of Jenny.

What else leaves me to say then; PROOF BY SEDUCTION is a debut novel told by emotion-driven characters that you will like from the get-go.

Quote Gareth:

He hungered for human connection. For contact, skin against skin. Soul against soul. And with Jenny, his most private name on her lips
4 stars

 post signature


  1. I agree...great characterization. Just loved Jenny and Gareth...plus the humor was a nice touch.

  2. To be honest the back blurb did nothing for me. I am so glad I read reviews and decided to pick it up.

    I really liked this book. I thought Milan did a great job with Gareth and Jenny. I was a little skeptical about reading a heroine who told fortunes...don't ask me why because I don't have an answer.

    Great review!

  3. I'm going to have to get this one. Just read the novella prequel to this story (which I loved), which made me want to get this book.

  4. Hi Leontine.
    Great review
    I sure like the premise of the story, and would love to see how it plays out

  5. Huge fan of Gareth - normally I hate the cold heroes who insult the heroine but in this case you know it's not really his fault. I loved how he botches his attempts to befriend White and his sister (although I really could have done without his dippy sister - after one paragraph I wanted to drop her down a nice, deep well).

  6. Hey Leontine! Love your review this one is next on my pile. Gareth sounds like my kind of hero!

  7. @Mandi - I really enjoyed the humor and was part of what made me read it so quickly :)

    @Smokinhotbooks - Then I won't ask *grin* Gareth and Jenny are just one of those couples that have the kind of chemistry that makes them stick out.

    @Lynette - Oh, have fun and I still need to read the prequel LOL

  8. @Blodeuedd - I hope you get your hands on a copy! It's definitely a great addition to your HR shelf ;)

    @AnimeJune - Oh yes I laughed when Gareth made his attempt to befriend White and how he regarded himself as a brother was a little heartbreaking.

    @Tricia - I hope you get to enjoy them :) I look forward to hearing your thoughts about it!

  9. Oooo I love me some imperfect heroes too, Leontine! And Yay!!! I have this one in my TBR.

    Thanks for the great review girl!


  10. Loved your review! I don't read that many historicals but I'll definitely want to try this one. I also heart a hero who knows he is imperfect but can’t help himself. And a couple with the right chemistry and a little bit of humor, what else does a girl need to wanna read a book :)

  11. Great review Leontine!!
    This book arrived shortly after release and I am dying to get to reading it, but with my Mt. TBR, the ARC/requests and a bunch of other highly anticipated releases it's going to be on the shelves for a bit still. I hope to get to it before the year ends LOL

  12. OMG...this does sound like a good one...and a new author! Wow, I really have to get this one!


  13. Such a great review. I so want to read this one. Just have to figure out the stupid Adobe Digital Editions.
    Sounds so good. Perhaps I should just buy it.

  14. Hi honey great review! I'm gonna have to get this one it sounds like a winner! I love finding new authors thanks hon and hope you are having a great one! HUGSSSSSS

  15. @VFG - Hon, you're so going to love Gareth, I feel he is a hero right up your alley ;)

    @Janna - Okay, you might like Courtney Milan bit if you want a historical with the smut level you are used to perhaps Lisa Valdez - Passion might be something that you will love too.

    @Pearl - You'll get there, I have faith :) And I hear ya, I sometimes think I will read that book ASAP, but that ASAP can take up as long as a few months LOL

  16. @HAWK - I hope you get to wrap your hands around a copy soon and enjoy it (((hugs)))

    @SusiSunshine - I actually read my dead tree copy because I wasn't going to read in front of pc and my e-reader runs on mobipocket not Adobe ;(

    @JennJ - Each year i find new authors and though my shelves are stacked I always find space for a new author LOL

  17. Thanks for the extra title for my TBB list ;) So, you think this one isn't smutty enough for me, huh? You're probably right then, LOL! Gonna check out the Lisa Valdez title!

  18. @Janna - Okay, I'm talking about Lisa Valdez in a Courtney Milan topic *headdesk* LOL There is an exhibition in England and it has a screen and they, Passion and Mark have several encounters behind it that doesn't say smut, it screams smut ;) *fans self*

  19. Great review hon, still have to read this one, looking forward to it!


I love to hear all your voices and opinions so thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment.